Boardroom

Share this post

🗳 This Week in Governance - Feb 16

governance.substack.com

🗳 This Week in Governance - Feb 16

A weekly resource covering crypto governance, politics, and power.

Duncan Dobbelmann
Feb 16
1
Share this post

🗳 This Week in Governance - Feb 16

governance.substack.com

📣 Key Points

  • Optimism governance moves on-chain

  • Spark Protocol forks Aave v3, proposes profit sharing

  • Uniswap considers an accountability committee

  • … and much more

Voting Activity (L7)
🗳️ 83,185 ballots
👥 24,315 voters
📜 276 proposals
🌐 71 active DAOs

Let’s get into it 🔥


🗞 News Brief

Optimism governance goes on-chain

On February 10th Optimism announced that their voting portal, which will facilitate on-chain voting for the Optimism Collective, is accessible for testing. Governance decisions have up until now been conducted off-chain through Snapshot, with very high (and increasing) participation from Token House voters. The Optimism Foundation, however, has for some time expressed the hope to move voting on-chain in order to increase decentralization — and to deal with persistent infrastructure issues. Various community members pressed for the transition as well. After a competitive selection process, Agora was chosen to build the portal, which will in action for the vote on Optimism’s protocol upgrade to Bedrock (starting on February 16th).

Spark Protocol forks Aave v3, proposes profit sharing

Last week Phoenix Labs announced its product Spark Protocol in the Maker forums. Intended as a “front-end for interacting with DAI,” Spark’s first offering is Spark Lend, a “market focused on the most liquid, decentralized, and highest market cap assets.” At the same time, Phoenix Labs posted in the Aave forums to acknowledge’s Spark’s roots in Aave v3 (i.e. Lend is a fork) and to propose a profit-sharing program “for the FOSS work done.”

The proposal is to send 10% of gross profits from the DAI market in Spark Lend to the Aave Treasury for a period of two years. Alternatively, Phoenix proposes that Spark could use 2% of that profit to purchase AAVE tokens and “align both organizations further”. Meanwhile, Aave recently announced that GHO, a new stablecoin and in some sense a competitor with DAI, is live on Ethereum’s Goerli testnet. Phoenix Labs says:

“We are ardent proponents of permissionless innovation that has enabled our space to create new and exciting solutions rapidly.”

Uniswap considers an accountability committee

Laura Lotti of Other Internet recently posted in the Uniswap forums to propose an Accountability Committee for Licensure and Deployments “tasked with overseeing the operational development of partnerships and agreements involving Additional Use Grant requests and deployments of Uniswap V3 on other chains.” Pointing to Uniswap’s Business Source License (which expires in April), the number of Additional Use Grants requested over the last year, and upcoming deployments of Uniswap V3 on other chains, the author makes a case for stringent oversight of the many processes involved, which include: evaluating proposals; implementing on-chain commitment mechanisms for the Uniswap DAO; providing quality assurance and technical guidance; and regular reporting to the DAO.

The initial proposed committee includes representatives from Consensys, she256, StableLab, Stanford Blockchain Club, and Tally — but further discussion has revealed interest from FranklinDAO (and potentially others). Should the proposal move forward, committee composition will likely be determined through the Uniswap governance process.


📚 Good Reads

  • “We read 59,000 DAO forum posts, so you don’t have to…*,” by Raphael Spannocchi of Flipside Crypto.

  • “Welcome Home: A New Kind of Social Network” from FWB

  • “Purple Innovation’s PRPLS Innovation” (corporate governance), by Matt Levine

  • “Finding the Right Leadership for your DAO,” by Kairon of Tally

Forums:

  • Bankless DAO: [RFC] bDAO Vacation Policy

  • Developer DAO: [DRAFT] D_D Cod of Conduct and Moderation Process

  • ENS: [Temp Check] ENS Token 2nd Airdrop

  • Euler: Formalizing Multichain Deployment Process

  • Lido: MEV policy for the Staking Router

  • Maker: Endgame Communications Strategy & Plan: Community Feedback

  • Paladin: Introducing a legal wrapper for Paladin

🧵 Threads

  • Token airdrops as incentive programs in the future, by Li Jin

  • Financial statements for DAOs, from Token Terminal

  • The three methods used to generate DAI, from Maker DAO

🎧 Listens

  • Collective Accountability and Lucid Dreaming with Gabriel Tumlos of Mochi, on DAO or Never

  • Uniswap BNB Deployment vote, Flipside’s Govy Show #21

  • BlochainGov community call: research on Proof of Humanity governance Crisis

  • Kraken to End Staking-As-A-Service Program, by Gary Gensler


📜 Highlighted Proposals

SafeDAO Constitution

View the proposal

With this proposal, Lukas Schor makes the case for a SafeDAO constitution. Arguing that improving human coordination through governance smart contracts isn’t sufficient, Schor lays out a draft text for the young DAO. The draft defines the “mission, goals, and principles” of the DAO that would together serve as the “north star” to guide the community. If approved, changes to the constitution would require double the quorum and a 2/3 majority vote.

✅ Voting starts Feb 16th
⏰ Voting ends: Feb 23rd
⚡ Type: Snapshot Vote
💬 Read the discussion
✍ Author: Lukas Schor

Swap Portion of Treasury USDC to DAI

View the proposal

ENS recently sold 25% of its treasury (which was entirely in ETH) for USDC, resulting in +$16m of the stablecoin, with the goal of providing an “operational runway” for the DAO that could last as long as two years. Monetsupply recently posted in the ENS forums to propose that $5m of the recently acquired USDC be swapped for DAI, and the DAI deposited into Maker’s DAI Savings Rate contract, which currently yields 1% interest. The author argues that this would present “meaningful diversification” and address such things as USDC solvency risk and centralization risk.

👥 Type: Temp-check
✍ Author: monet-supply

RFP: Cayman Islands Administrator for the APE Foundation

View the proposal

This request for proposals was posted to the ApeCoin DAO forum on February 7th, pointing out the need for a new administrator of the APE Foundation “to support the governance and administration of activities of the DAO.” The described scope of work is significant and includes finances, legal and regulatory compliance, meeting facilitation, and social media account and Apecoin website maintenance. Submission guidelines and submission evaluation criteria are detailed. Four companies have responded to the request; one of them proposes to fulfill all functions, while the remaining three propose to work together in doing the same. Projected costs are ~$75k/month.

👥 Type: Forum discussion
✍ Author: Waabam


💭 Ecosystem Takes

Twitter avatar for @pet3rpan_
pet3rpan @pet3rpan_
The social tokens vision came true. They were just NFTs as opposed to ERC-20s.
4:57 PM ∙ Feb 15, 2023
26Likes5Retweets
Twitter avatar for @Vonnie610
⭐ Vee 🔴✨ @Vonnie610
If you make a governance system where power is measured in money, don’t be surprised when someone buys the vote. Thanks for coming to my ted talk.
4:36 PM ∙ Feb 13, 2023
18Likes2Retweets
Twitter avatar for @MonetSupply
monetsupply.lens @MonetSupply
my personal opinion is, multisig heavy projects should be sprinting at max speed towards substantive decentralization - on chain governance - strict limits on team control of funds - minimizing dependence on favorable market conditions for one's own gov token
12:18 AM ∙ Feb 11, 2023
65Likes9Retweets

🎈 Have a Meme

Twitter avatar for @JimmyRagosa
Jimmy Ragosa | Jrag.eth @JimmyRagosa
@owocki
Image
5:16 PM ∙ Feb 15, 2023

📮 Stay Up to Date

Follow us: Twitter | Discord
Subscribe to: Newsletter | Mirror | Apple | Spotify


📣 New ideas for this newsletter or the dashboard?

Drop us a comment or request using the link below!

Ideas and Feature Requests

Share this post

🗳 This Week in Governance - Feb 16

governance.substack.com
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Kevin Nielsen
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing